Dine-In and Take-Out Menus
Menus
Our in-house dining and take-out hours are
Tuesday thru Saturday 5pm to 9pm
In-house Diners
may order from either food menus
- Lunch! Featuring Hog Island Hoagie - Best built hoagies this side of Philly
- Soda Pops and Herr's Chips for lunch
- In-House, Take-out and Delivery.
- Drinks
From 11am to 3pm Monday thru Friday
Hoagies
-
The Hog Islander
Classic Italian - Black Forest ham, Genoa salami, ham coppa, provolone, mortadella, hot cherry peppers, Mama Lil's Peppers, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, mayo, salt/pepper, oil/vinegar, oregano flake
$14
-
American Hero
Black Fores ham, Genoa salami, mortadella, white American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, pepperoncini, mayo, deli mustard, salt/pepper, oil/vinegar
$13
add/extra Mama Lil's $0.50
add/extra Hot Cherry Peppers $0.50
add/extra giardiniera $0.50
add/extra pickles $0.50
add/extra pepperoncinis $0.50
add/extra tapanade $0.50
add/extra cucumbers $0.50
Extra cheese $1.50
Extra Meat $2.50
add/extra red bell peppers $0.50
-
King Solomon
Angus roast beef, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pepperoncini, pickles, horseradish sauce, deli mustard, salt/pepper, oil/vinegar
$13
add/extra Mama Lil's peppers $0.50
add/extra hot peppers $0.50
add/extra giardiniera $0.50
add/extra tapanade $0.50
add/extra pickles $0.50
add/extra English cucumbers $0.50
add/extra red bell peppers $0.50
add/extra cheese $1.50
add/extra meat $2.50
add/extra pepperoncini $0.50
-
Chicago Dock
Angus roast beef, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, giardiniera, pickles, pepperoncini, mayo, deli mustard, salt/pepper, oil/vinegar
$13
add/extra Mama Lil's peppers $0.50
add/extra hot peppers $0.50
add/extra giardiniera $0.50
add/extra tapanade $0.50
add/extra English cucumbers $0.50
add/extra red bell peppers $0.50
add/extra pepperoncini $0.50
add/extra giardiniera $0.50
Extra cheese $1.50
Extra Meat $2.50
-
British Armada
Black forest ham, premium carvery turkey, Angus roast beef, white cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, pepperonicini, mayo, deli mustard, salt/pepper, oil/vinegar
$13
add/extra Mama Lil's peppers $0.50
add/extra hot peppers $0.50
add/extra giardiniera $0.50
add/extra Tapanade $0.50
add/extra pepperoncini $0.50
add/extra English cucumbers $0.50
add/extra red bell peppers $0.50
add/extra pepperoncini $0.50
Extra cheese $1.50
Extra Meat $2.50
-
Commodore
Black forest ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese, oven-roasted tomato/Greek olive tapanade, giardiniera, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, pepperoncini, oil/vinegar, oregano flake
$13
add/extra Mama Lil's peppers $0.50
add/extra hot peppers $0.50
add/extra pepperoncini $0.50
add/extra pickles $0.50
add/extra giardiniera $0.50
add/extra tapanade $0.50
add/extra English cucumbers $0.50
add/extra red bell peppers $0.50
Extra cheese $1.50
Extra meat $2.50
-
Ship Builer
choice (choose just one meat please), choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, pepperoncini, mayo, deli mustard, salt/pepper, oil/vinegar
$13
meat choice is Premium Carvery Turkey
meat choice is Angus Roast Beef
meat choice is Black Forest Ham
cheese choice is White American
cheese choice is White Cheddar
cheese choice is Pepper Jack
cheese choice is Provolone
Cheese Choice is Muenster
add/extra Mama Lil's peppers $0.50
add/extra hot peppers $0.50
add/extra pepperoncini $0.50
add/extra pickles $0.50
add/extra giardiniera $0.50
add/extra tapanade $0.50
add/extra English cucumbers $0.50
add/extra red bell peppers $0.50
Extra cheese $1.50
Extra Meat $2.50
-
Skipjack
tuna salad, choice of cheese, onions, giardiniera, pickles, pepperoncini, lettuce, oil/vinegar, paprika dust
$13
cheese choice is White American
cheese choice is White Cheddar
cheese choice is Pepper Jack
cheese choice is Provolone
cheese choice is Muenster
add/extra Mama Lil's peppers $0.50
add/extra hot peppers $0.50
add/extra pepperoncini $0.50
add/extra pickles $0.50
add/extra giardiniera $0.50
add/extra tapanade $0.50
add/extra English cucumbers $0.50
add/extra red bell peppers $0.50
Extra cheese $1.50
Extra Tuna $2.50
-
Vashon Veggie
choice of cheese, oven -roasted tomato/Greek olive tapanade, lettuce, tomato, onion, English cucumbers, red bell peppers, pepperoncini, salt/pepper, oil/vinegar, oregano flake
$13
-
No Hog Hoagie
Vegan version of the Hog Islander made with all the same fillings but with Vegan mayo, wild mushroom Field Roast, and creamy original tofu cheese
$13
Hot Hoagies (Grinders)
-
SW Ship Rock
premium carvery turkey, fire roasted hatch peppers, jalapeno peppers, onions, pepper jack cheese, Southwest cilantro/lime/jalapeno aioli, and a touch of chipotle aioli
$14
-
Brass Pounder
Our meatloaf hoagie - meatloaf with ketchup glaze, bacon aoil, deli mustard, pickles, grilled onions, muenster cheese
$14
-
Captain's Club
premium carvery turkey, Black forest ham, bacon, tomato, muenster cheese, lime/cilantro/jalapeno aoli
$14
-
Shipyard Cheesesteak
tender grilled Angus roast beef, grilled onions, choice of cheese (white American, provolone, cheez whiz) Make it St. Louis style with Provel cheese - a gooey combination of cheddar, Swiss, and provolone. Imported from Imo's Pizza in St. Louis, MO *Mama Lil's and Hot Peppers for free if you like.
$14
cheese choice is White American
cheese choice is Cheez Whiz
cheese choice is Provolone
Make it Provel! $2
-
Shipyard Turkey Cheesesteak
tender grilled premium carvery turkey, grilled onions, choice of cheese (white American, Cheez Whiz, provolone Make it St. Lous style with Provel cheese - a gooey combination of cheddar, Swiss, provolone Imported from Imo's Pizza in St. Louis, MO *Mama Lil's and Hot Peppers free if you like.
$14
cheese choice is White American
cheese choice is Cheez Whiz
cheese choice is Provolone
make it Provel! $2
-
Saint Louis Gooey cheesesteak
A Hog Island/Petoskey's Midwest Pizza Original - Tender Angus roast beef, grilled onions, Cheez Whiz, and a generous portion of Provel cheese from Imo's Pizza in St. Louis, MO. Mama Lils and Hot Peppers for free if you like.
$16
Soda Pop
-
Mac Fuddy's Pepper Elixer - like Dr. Pepper $3.50
Jersey Cream $3.50
O So Grape $3.50
Triple Cola $3.50
Bull Dog Rootbeer $3.30
Herr's Chips from Pensylvania
-
Chips
Sour Cream and Onion $1.50
Crisp N Tasty $1.50
Salt and Vinegar $1.50
Old Bay 2 3/8oz. $3.50
Chickie's & Pete's Crabfries 2.75oz. $3.50
ketchup $1.50
Open Tuesdays thru Saturday
for dine in, delivery & take out!
We will be offering food from our dinner menu for delivery & take out menu
5 pm- 9 pm
Apps
-
Buffalo Wings
Classic Buffalo Sauce, Blue Cheese Dressing, Celery
-
Fried Cheese Curds
Kaufold’s Kurds From Ellesworth, Wisconsin. Only the best.
-
Beer Battered Pickles
Chicago's own Chipico Pickle chips. Golden fried. With Ranch Dip
-
Toasted Ravioli
Straight from Imo’s in St. Louis, 8 beef filled ravioli served with Marinara
Large sides
-
Basket Tater Tots or Fries
-
Truffle Fries or Truffle Tater Tots
Salads
-
Caesar Salad
Classic or add Bacon for $3 more
$3 - $3
Burgers and Sandwiches
Choice of Fries or Tots Sub Caesar Salad $2-
Jucy Lucy
Minnesota Original -8oz Patty Cheddar & American Stuffed Burger, Chopped Pickle & Onion, Burger Sauce, Brioche Bun
$17
-
Garden Vegan Burger
Assortment of veggies combined and sauteed in our Perfect Vegan Patty. w/lettuce & tomato on a Brioche Bun. - Please ask for mayo.
-
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Brioche Bun
Add Cheese $1.50
Add Bacon $3
-
Crispy Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Smothered in Buffalo Sauce, Bleu Cheese dressing, Lettuce, Tomato, Brioche Bun
Petoskey's Midwest Dogs
-
Chicago Dog
Dragged through the garden with White Onion, Sweet Pickle Relish, Kosher Dill Pickle Spear, Tomato Slices, Celery Salt, Plochman’s Yellow Mustard
Supper
-
Petoskey’s Amazing “Hat Trick” Mac ‘n Cheese
Seashell Macaroni smothered and baked in a whole lot of cheeses and topped with more cheese and topped with our Cornflake crust before a final bake in our wood fired oven.
PETOSKEY'S SIGNATURE WOOD FIRED MIDWEST STYLE THIN CUT PIZZA
14” Square Cut Pies Cooked In Our Wood Fired Oven. Red Sauce Base Unless Noted Otherwise | Topped with 100% Wisconsin Mozzarella. Substitute Imo’s St. Louis Provel for $2 Upcharge-
The Great Mike Petoskey
Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Black Olive, Bell Pepper, Mushroom, Onion
-
Mac & Cheese Pizza
Topped with Mozzarella, Petoskey’s Amazing “Hat Trick” Mac ‘n Cheese, and Pepperoni
-
The Classic Green Olive!
Green Olives, Canadian Bacon and Roasted Garlic
-
Mackinac Island
Canadian bacon, Pineapple, Jalapeno
-
Hat Trick Mac & Cheese
Pepperoni, Petoskey’s Hat Trick Macaroni & Cheese
-
Detroiter
Bacon, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Tomato, Jalapeno, Onion
-
St. Louis Cheeseburger
Ground Beef, Bacon, Onion, Provel Cheese
-
Blue Earth Minnesota
Red and Green Bell Pepper, Black Olive, Mushroom, Onion
-
Relaxed Viking
Olive Oil Base, Tomato, Roasted Garlic, Red Onion, Kalamata, Onion, Artichoke hearts
-
Build Your Own
14" Square cut pies cooked in our Wood Fire Oven. Red Sauce Base (except Relaxed Viking)
Mushroom, Onion, Pineapple, Jalapeno $1.75
Black Olive, Green Olive, Bell Pepper, Banana Pepper, Tomato, Sauerkraut $2
Pepperoni, Chicago Italian Sausage, Ground Beef, Canadian bacon, Artichoke Hearts, Kalamata Olive, Bacon $2.50
Add Provel $3
Dessert
-
St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake
$8
Wine
We are proud to offer Family Owned Barnard Griffin Wines from Richland, Washington.-
Barnard Griffin Featured Red
-
Barnard Griffin Featured Rose
-
Barnard Griffin Featured White
-
Brut Cava, Bodegas Bonaval, Spain
Beer
-
Draft Beers and Ciders
Come in and check out our rotating drafts. *You will always find Hamm's and Founders on tap, as well as 5 other rotating local and Midwest beers and ciders.
-
Bottles & Cans
All the Leinenkugel's we can get. All the Founder's we can get. Plus a great variety of local and Midwest beers and ciders. Petoskey's staple Lawnmower Beers are Miller Hi Life, Miller Lite, Coors Light, Corona, Molson Canadian, and Labatt's Blue. Petoskey's Staple Tall Boy Cans are Rainier, Olympia, and PBR.
Cocktails
-
Minnesota Bootleg
House Infused Fresh Mint Vodka, Lemon/ Limeade, and soda
-
Viking Tea
Mischief Vodka, Empress Jasmin Gin, Fresh Batched Sour, triple sec, and sprite. Served with a lemon garnish. Purple and Gold!
-
Mike’s Old Fashioned
Old Forester Bourbon, Angostura Bitters, Demerara, Orange, and a Luxardo Cherry
-
Wisconsin Old Fashioned
Korbel Brandy, Angostura Bitters, Sugar, Luxurdo Cherry, Orange, Option to top off with Sprite (Wisconsin Style)
-
Michigan Astronaut
Don Q Cristal, Don Q Coco, Don Q 151 rum, pineapple, lemon, lime, dash of grenadine
-
SotaPop
Prairie Vodka, Lemon, Grape, Soda
-
Minnesota Martini
(Celebratory drink after the founding of Minnesota. It lives on) Pint of Hamm’s, Shot of Evan Williams
Shots & Drop Shots $7
-
SKOL!
Vodka, Blue Curacao, and a dash of cranberry
-
The St. Louis Blue Drop Shot - Our Victory Shot
Pint of Bud, Evan Williams Whiskey, & Blue Curacao
-
Gopher
Rum, Chambord, Pineapple
-
Spartan
Tequila, sour apple, lemon and lime-Salted Rim
-
Missou Black and Gold
Black - Kalua and Frangelico
Gold - Splash of Budweiser
-
Badger
Fireball, Goldschlager and grenadine